When ready to bake, spread mixture in a greased baking dish, and bake uncovered at 350 ˚ for 45 minutes or until bubbly. It should be fine in the fridge for up to two days. Keep it refrigerated until ready to bake. Simply combine the pasta and all ingredients, mix well, and store in the fridge in a ziploc bag. The recipe can be made a day or two ahead. This mac & cheese is a great make ahead dish. The cottage cheese curds will be visible when the dish is baked, but this adds to the rustic appearance of the dish. I have used small and large curd for this recipe either one works perfectly fine. The best cottage cheese to use for this recipe will be 2% fat or higher. What kind of cottage cheese is best for mac & cheese? When using 12 ounces, you might choose to reserve some to sprinkle on the top before baking. You can use 10-12 ounces~whichever you choose.

Packaged pre-shredded cheese is not going to give the same fabulous results. It takes only a few minutes and a little elbow grease to do this, and a box grater works beautifully. The dish bakes into a cheesy, creamy tangy mac & cheese that is incredibly delicious.īest results come from a good quality sharp or extra sharp white cheddar that you grate by hand. These ingredients are mixed together in a bowl, and the pasta is added once it is cooked. Instead, the sauce is a combination of cottage cheese, sour cream, white cheddar, and one egg. Traditional mac & cheese calls for a homemade roux made with flour and milk. No roux is necessary for this mac & cheese. Because it travels well, it is easy to make and take to the lake, beach or a party. She brought it to the lake for the family to enjoy, and it has been a favorite ever since. It is SO easy to make, and it is absolutely delicious. My sister-in-law found the recipe in a decades old Alabama Power cookbook and tweaked it slightly. My sister-in-law shared this gem of a recipe. It adds great creaminess and tons of protein. I use cottage cheese sometimes in lasagna. Yes!!! Don’t worry, it is FABULOUS!! It may look at bit different (you’ll see the curds), but it just works. I made this a few days ago, and my husband and daughters RAVED!! They all declared this the best Mac & Cheese they’ve ever tasted. We’ve been eating lots of basic, simple, satisfying comfort meals during this time. I’ve had this recipe for years, but only pulled it out recently during the pandemic which has had us all staying home.

Cottage cheese is a surprise ingredient in the best EVER white cheddar mac & cheese that kids and adults RAVE about!

Best baked white mac and cheese recipe